Beacon Hill Named After Lost Lighthouse

A concept sketch of how the lighthouse in the Ottawa River may have looked based on a photo taken by Lou Bouchard circa 1960s.

A concept sketch of how the lighthouse in the Ottawa River may have looked based on a photo taken by Lou Bouchard and aerial images from the 1960s.

The east-Ottawa community of Beacon Hill has a history of celebrity upbringing since the early 1970s when the suburban neighbourhood was originally developed. Tom Cruise, then known as Thomas Mapother, lived in Beacon Hill in the early 1970s along with another Hollywood Tom, the home-grown comedian Tom Green. Bryan Adams and former Saturday Night Live cast member and Weekend Update anchor Norm MacDonald also spent their youth in this east end suburb located a few kilometers downstream from the Nation’s Capital.

Having attracted a number of celebrities, the area also has a history of keeping people away from its shores with the construction of a warning beacon, the very beacon that gave the community its name.

This old 1880 map clearly shows a lighthouse in between the Duck Islands on the Ottawa River.

This old 1880 map clearly shows a lighthouse in between the Duck Islands on the Ottawa River. (Gloucester Township Map 1880)

A few hundred metres north of the shore near Beacon Hill lie the remains of one of the Ottawa River’s lost lighthouses. Constructed in 1860 between the gaps of the the Ducks Islands near the provincial border, the lighthouse structure was built as a navigational aid to warn sailors of the dangerous reef of rocks known as “Green Shoal”. Navigating ships on the Ottawa River was a relatively new adventure in the mid-19th century, but with the construction of the Rideau Canal in 1832 and the Carillon Canal in 1833, the Ottawa River became a busy shipping and tourist route between Ottawa, Lake Ontario and Montreal before the advent of area rail travel. The waterway was busy with steamships plying the waves between cities, but a number of shoals and islands created hazards for the vessels and required the need for warning lights to mark their location. The government at the time gave the order for the construction of approximately 30 lighthouses on the Ottawa River to assist in the safe passage of growing river traffic. Pre-Confederation Canadian lighthouses were usually built of stone or brick, but with the need to build so many new structures in time, the newly formed Department of Marine and Fisheries required cheaper and faster lighthouse construction techniques.

A 1904 map shows lighthouses in red, a number of which were on the Ottawa River.

A 1904 map shows lighthouses in red, a number of which were on the Ottawa River. The Beacon Hill lighthouse, on Green Shoal, is the furthest red dot on the left. (bytown.net -Department of the Interior, Atlas of Canada 1904)

Built as four sided tapering wooden clapboard towers, these structures had the advantage of being cheap to build, and in some cases could be relocated if the site needed attention. The water hazard known as Green Shoal would seen see the construction of such a beacon structure in 1860 on a conical pedestal sheathed in iron boiler plates, riveted together like some kind of Jules Verne rocket to withstand the strong river current and sheets of crushing ice carried downstream. Atop this iron clad pedestal was placed a 4 sided white wooden pyramidal tower 21 feet in height. Using a standard design used for many of the Ottawa River lighthouses, the structure housed a fixed light that was initially fueled by Kerosene, a fuel invented by the Canadian geologist Abraham Gesner in 1846. The Green Shoal light was visible to passing ships from a distance of nine miles and eventually was rebuilt in 1900 when it was most likely converted to using an electric lamp.

In 1862 the Sessional Papers of the Province of Canada reveal a house was requested to be built for the keeper of the lighthouse, yet its location or fate is unknown. In 1891 the lighthouse keeper by the name of A. Laberge earned an annual salary of $250 for his duties maintaining the light at Green Shoal.

A 1965 aerial image shows that the beacon was still in place on its pedestal on the Ottawa River.

A close-up of a 1965 aerial image shows that the beacon was still in place on its pedestal on the Ottawa River. (geoOttawa)

The beacon remained in operation for more than a hundred years, being dismantled and replaced by an automated light marker sometime in the 1970s. It was at this time that a new suburb was being developed nearby, and from atop the hill on what is now Naskapi Drive, the neighbourhood got its name from the old beacon that was visible on the river below.

The location of the ruins of the lost lighthouse that gave Beacon Hill its name.

The location of the ruins of the lost lighthouse that gave Beacon Hill its name. (Google Maps)

Today Beacon Hill residents and those on the Quebec side of the river can catch a glimpse of the iron-clad lighthouse ruins sitting in the Ottawa River. Bashed by years of crushing river ice, the rusty remnants now list to one side, a forgotten sentinel literally frozen in time during the winter months.

All that remains of the lighthouse are the iron-clad rusty remnants of the beacon's pedestal.

All that remains of the lighthouse are the iron-clad rusty remnants of the beacon’s pedestal. (Bing Maps)

The beacon ruins, literally frozen in time, encased in ice on the Ottawa River. The neighbourhood of Beacon Hill, which got its name from this very lighthouse,  is in the background.

The rusting beacon ruins, literally frozen in time, encased in ice on the Ottawa River. The neighbourhood of Beacon Hill, which got its name from this very lighthouse, is in the background.

 

Beacon Hill, a neighbourhood that could also be called “Celebrity Hill”, continues to carry the name of the structure that once warned sailors to keep away. What’s left of this namesake slowly slips under the waves from where it emerged.

SOURCES

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beacon_Hill,_Ottawa

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tom_Cruise

http://www.bytown.net/lighthouses.htm

Lighthouse Digest Magazine Database http://www.lighthousedigest.com/Digest/database/uniquelighthouse.cfm?value=2998BING MAPS

1891 Sessional Papers Canadian Parliament -Report Of Dominion Fisheries Canada

1862 Sessional Papers Of The Province Of Canada

GOOGLE MAPS

HIDDEN FORTRESS: 17th CENTURY FORT ON THE OTTAWA RIVER

A 17th century stone fortress ruin lies in someone's backyard on the banks of the Ottawa River 90minutes east of Ottawa.

A 17th century stone fortress ruin lies in someone’s backyard on the banks of the Ottawa River 90minutes east of Ottawa. (photo: Google Maps)

fortsenneville

When you think of a stone castle fort with gun ports and swiveling cannon bastions, images of European castle fortresses probably come to mind. A stone fortification that repels invaders with projections for pouring hot liquids and/or rocks down on attackers seems in place within medieval Europe, but yet this castle fortress lies not there, but on the Ottawa River. Hidden amidst trees in someone’s backyard, there lies the ruins of a 17th century stone fortress.

Aerial image of what remains of Fort Senneville built in 1692. (photo: Google Maps)

Aerial image of what remains of Fort Senneville built in 1692. (photo: Google Maps)

Approximately 160km east of Ottawa hidden from view on the banks of the Ottawa River sit the remains of Fort Senneville, a 17th century stone castle-fort built to protect French settlers. The fortress ruins sit in the backyard of a residence on Senneville Road, designated a National Historic Site, but out of view from the general public. The fort can however be seen with the use of aerial images such as Google Maps and Bing Maps where we can further study this fascinating piece of history under the trees.

Location of the fort in relation to Ottawa.

Location of the fort in relation to Ottawa.

Closer aerial view showing the location of the fort.

Closer aerial view showing the location of the fort.

Google streetview showing the entrance to the private residence where the fortress sits in their backyard.

Google streetview showing the entrance to the private residence where the fortress sits in their backyard.

The fort is the westernmost stone fortification built by the French on the Ottawa River when they constructed a protective string of 30 outlying forts to repel the Iroquois threat to the expansion of French settlements. Originally the fort was constructed of wood in 1671 and was attacked by the Iroquois in 1687, a year after a fortified stone mill was built on the site that also served as a watchtower overlooking the Ottawa River. The initial attack was repulsed, but the Iroquois returned in greater force in 1691 when they successfully attacked and burned the wooden fort to the ground.

A map from 1744 showing the location of Fort Senneville.

A map from 1744 showing the location of Fort Senneville.

Governor-General Frontenac then ordered the construction of a stronger, more substantial fort, and in 1692 Fort Senneville was constructed using thick stone walls and corner tower bastions, cannon ports, musket ports, and extensive swivel wall guns. Fort Senneville on the Ottawa River was the “most substantial castle-like fort” near Montreal.

My conceptual sketch of how Fort Senneville may have looked in the 1700's

My conceptual sketch of how Fort Senneville may have looked in the 1700’s

Top view sketch of the fort footprint near the Ottawa River.

Top view sketch of the fort footprint near the Ottawa River.

This new fortress was never attacked again. It remained a stronghold on the easternmost end of the Ottawa River near where it meets the St. Lawrence River, a strategic location for shipping and fur trading operations.

This imposing castle-like French fortress was ceded to the British in 1763 after the fall of New France and it remained an unused outpost. However, in 1776 during the American Revolutionary War, the fort was doomed.

Benedict Arnold, who destroyed the fort in 1776.

Benedict Arnold, who destroyed the fort in 1776.

Benedict Arnold leading his Continental Army troops in military maneuvers during the Battle Of The Cedars took over the fort and burned it to the ground as they retreated back to the United States. Arnold successfully destroyed the fort before he switched sides and joined the British around 1780.

Benedict Arnold took over then later burned the fort as he retreated to the USA during the American Revolutionary War in 1776.

Benedict Arnold took over, then later burned the fort as he retreated to the USA during the American Revolutionary War in 1776.

The ruined Fort Senneville was purchased in 1865 as a summer residence by the former prime minister of Canada and mayor of Montreal, John Abbott. The property then changed hands again in 1898 to Edward Clouston, the General Manager of the Bank Of Montreal.

A photograph of the fort exposing the ruins when the foliage has cleared during the autumn season.

A photograph of the fort exposing the ruins when the foliage has cleared during the autumn season.

A Google Map image showing what remains of the 17th century fortress.

A Google Map image showing what remains of the 17th century fortress.

BM99-0127

Artwork from 1831 showing the ruins of the fort, which look to be in good condition at the time.

 

Since then the property has been privately owned and the hidden stone fortress remains cloaked under trees on the shores of the Ottawa River. It was designated in 2003 by Quebec for historical significance by classifying it as a “site historique” . Archaeological research and repairs funded by the Ministry of Culture and Communications has helped preserve what remains, and in 2009 it became a National Historic Site.

91983

This aerial image shows the modern residences nearby with the fort in their backyard.

Bing Map image showing the ruins of the fort near the Ottawa River.

Bing Map image showing the ruins of the fort near the Ottawa River.

 

The ruins of the fort continue to be under private ownership and public access is not allowed. It is interesting to think that what remains of the largest stone castle-like fortress on the Ottawa River from the 17th century remains hidden in someone’s backyard, out of sight for those of us that aren’t invited to their backyard barbecue.

ATLAS SHRUGGED: Ottawa’s Landmark Rocket To Be Cut Up

 

PHOTO : Intiaz Rahim

PHOTO : Intiaz Rahim

The Museum Of Science and Technology recently announced that their iconic rocket displayed on the grounds of the museum is slated to be destroyed after more than forty years. The museum stated “For safety reasons related to their deterioration, the Atlas rocket and the oil pumpjack that have for many years graced the lawns of Technology Park in front of the Canada Science and Technology Museum (CSTM) will be removed.” according to a recent article in the Ottawa Citizen. (read complete article here)

The museum has already been forced to close due to air quality concerns, so this recent announcement comes as a second blow for the cash-strapped facility that houses some of this country’s most historic artifacts. The rocket is on loan from the USAF who says they don’t want it back, but rather ask it be “cut down into tiny pieces so that no one could possibly figure out how to reassemble them.”

The destruction of our beloved and popular landmark will occur over the course of the next few weeks, but before that happens, let’s take a closer look at our famous rocket before it is sadly gone forever.

Our rocket is an Atlas 5A (Serial #56-6742) and it is the only surviving Atlas in the original A-series configuration. The first Atlas flown was the Atlas A in 1957–1958. Our rocket was built in 1956 used as a test and research article, later displayed  throughout the 1960s at the former location of the Air Force Museum, at Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio.

Our Rocket as it appeared on display in the United States before arriving in Ottawa.

Our Rocket as it appeared on display in the United States before arriving in Ottawa.

The Atlas-class rocket was used to put Lt. Col. John Glenn in space becoming the first American to orbit the Earth in 1962 and was also the first intercontinental ballistic missile. (ICBM) . Nuclear ICBM launch silos were built across the US during the cold war to facilitate nuclear armed Atlas rockets. The Atlas was retired from service in 1965.

An Atlas rocket with the Mercury capsule attached circa 1963.

An Atlas rocket with the Mercury capsule attached circa 1963.

One such missile silo exists just south east of Ottawa in Upper New York state, Here is a Google pic of the abandoned Atlas ICBM silo located just a two hour drive from Ottawa.

IMG_4045The rocket was loaned to the museum in Ottawa by the USAF in 1973 when it was installed on the front lawn of the museum..

After more than forty years outside  in the harsh elements, the rocket has now deteriorated to the point, that according to the article it “has not been air tight for many years, and a compressor coupled to a generator (has) been required to maintain its internal pressure to prevent it from collapsing upon itself,”

Pressure in the tanks provides the structural rigidity and an Atlas rocket would collapse under its own weight if not kept pressurized with 5 psi of nitrogen in the tank even when not fuelled. The compound WD-40 was invented in 1953 by Dr. Norm Larsen, founder of the Rocket Chemical Company and first used by Convair to protect the outer skin of the rocket, more importantly, the paper-thin balloon tanks of the Atlas missile from rust and corrosion. These stainless steel fuel tanks were so thin that, when empty, they had to be kept inflated with the nitrogen gas to prevent their collapse.

The museum sates that “As its deterioration advances and becomes more severe, practical solutions to maintain the required internal pressure to prevent it from crumpling and potentially injuring visitors to Technology Park are running out.”

A sad end to a rocket that launched the imaginations of thousands of kids over the last four decades. You’d think we’d be able to find an alternative way save this valuable piece of world history. Does anyone have the Smithsonian’s number?

UPDATE FEBRUARY 22 2015

After recently contacting the Smithsonian Air and Space Museum about the doomed rocket, they put me in touch with Discovery Park Museum in Tennessee. There is a slim chance the rocket may have a new home and avoid being cut up.

FULL update in the Ottawa Citizen here:

SOURCES

Ottawa Citizen, February 10 2015 http://ottawacitizen.com/news/local-news/science-and-tech-museum-will-lose-rocket-pumpjack

Wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SM-65_Atlas

http://www.atlasmissilesilo.com/556thSMS_Site11.htm

Google Maps

 

 

 

THE IRON GIANT: Smiths Falls 100 year old bascule bridge

WATCH THE AMAZING DRONE FILM FOOTAGE OF THE IRON GIANT by Dan Brennan of B4CK40

A Smiths Falls landmark for over a hundred years, the giant iron bridge on the outskirts of town that once spanned across the Rideau Canal sits like a massive sentinel, forever poised at a 45 degree angle.  Built by the Canadian Northern Railway over the course of the year 1912-13, the bridge was part of the Toronto to Ottawa connection of the CNR. Designed in Chicago and built by the Dominion Bridge Company, this massive iron bridge showcased a new style of bridge engineering fairly new to North America called the bascule bridge.

The bridge as it looked in 1988. (photo Parks Canada)

The bridge as it looked in 1988. (photo Parks Canada)

Called the Schrezer Rolling Lift Bascule bridge, after the Chicago company who designed it, these bridges were designed for areas where a high rail bridge or swing bridge could not be implemented. “Bascule” is French for “see-saw”, the principle used in its design and operation. Using a massive concrete counterweight perfectly balanced, the bridge lifted up with relative ease by either manual or electric operation. The bridge first began operating by manual fashion, but in 1914 a DC electric motor was installed to raise the bridge, but in 1915, the town of Smiths Falls switched to AC electric current, making the bridge motor useless. It went back to being manually operated until 1978. The CNR line later closed, and the bridge was put in a permanent “up position” which is how it remains to this day.

The bridge in its fixed upright state. (photo Wikipedia)

The bridge in its fixed upright state. (photo Wikipedia)

 

The Iron Giant in Smiths Falls.

The Iron Giant in Smiths Falls.

The bridge is the oldest surviving structure of its type in Canada and is in the care of the City Of Smiths Falls who claimed ownership of the bridge in the mid-1980s. It can easily be visited by foot and every year hundreds of boats pass beneath its  ironwork as they travel under this looming iron giant on the Rideau Canal system. It was designated a National Historic Site in 1983.

SOURCES

Parks Canada http://www.pc.gc.ca/APPS/CP-NR/release_e.asp?bgid=559&andor1=bg

Canada’s Historic Places http://www.historicplaces.ca/en/rep-reg/place-lieu.aspx?id=7867

 

Sleeping Prince: A look at re-using the Prince Of Wales Bridge

Concept of the O-train crossing the Ottawa River on the dormant Prince Of Wales bridge.

Concept of the O-train crossing the Ottawa River on the dormant Prince Of Wales bridge.

The oldest railway bridge in Ottawa is being considered for a pedestrian/bike path. Finally something is being done to make use of our Prince Of Wales bridge, an Ottawa River landmark built in 1880 that was abandoned in 2001. Since then it has simply been a magnet for daredevils and graffiti. Yet, this solid link to Gatineau could also be re-purposed for something more, making it a vital connection to help alleviate the growing commuter traffic that continues to clog area bridges carrying hundreds of cars at Island Park Drive, Chaudiere, Alexandra Bridge and the Macdonald-Cartier Bridge. A simple gap of a few hundred metres, bureaucracy and money stands between continuing the O-train across the bridge to the Gatineau side using the old existing rail beds and bridge, a purpose for which the Prince Of Wales Bridge was designed for.

1965 aerial image showing the original Canadian Pacific rail line that crossed the Ottawa River on the bridge.

1965 aerial image showing the original Canadian Pacific rail line that crossed the Ottawa River on the bridge. -geoOttawa

It was built in 1880 by the Phoenix Bridge Company for the Québec, Montréal, Ottawa and Occidental Railway to cross the Ottawa River near the busy industrial area of Lebreton Flats and Chaudiere Falls. A few years later the bridge and line was purchased by Canadian Pacific Railway who later modified the bridge in 1926 when they replaced the iron work with heavier iron trusses that could carry heavier rail loads between the two sides. The PoW bridge continued to carry rail traffic until 2001 when the last train chugged across.

The bridge was soon purchased for its scrap value by the City Of Ottawa, but the purchase included the approach land on BOTH sides of the river, which means the City Of Ottawa owns property on the Gatineau/Quebec side. Curiously, the intact tracks that would have led from the newly operating O-train line were disconnected and removed crossing the NCC property during their Lebreton Flats re-vitalization project in 2005.

The Prince Of Wales bridge could utilize the old connection with the existing O-train and continue across the river to Gatineau.

The Prince Of Wales bridge could utilize the old connection (removed in 2005) with the existing O-train and continue across the river to Gatineau. -geoOttawa

It seems like an odd and unnecessary action to literally derail future extension of the O-train over to Gatineau using the PoW bridge, that with some forward thinking upgrades, could certainly ease commuter traffic if properly implemented.

In addition to extending the O-train, of which the original rail beds still exist, future modifications could also see the addition of a pedestrian/cycling path built on the side, much like the one on the Alexandra Bridge further down river.

Currently abandoned, the old bridge could be re-purposed as a cycling/pedestrian river crossing and possibly an O-train extension. -photo Wikipedia public domain

Currently abandoned, the old bridge could be re-purposed as a cycling/pedestrian river crossing and possibly an O-train extension. -photo Wikipedia public domain

With these modifications to a solid, timeless bridge already in place we could certainly help decrease growing commuter traffic building up on our bridges while increasing healthy alternatives to crossing the river with a safe cycling and pedestrian crossing, which is lacking on other bridges.

As I’m sure there are many bureaucratic roadblocks and prohibitive costs involved on both sides of the river that I don’t know about, and there are engineering details that could simply make this a dream, maybe with enough public support for such a vision it could become reality. With the City Of Ottawa owning both the bridge AND the land it connects to on both sides of the river, one has to wonder how the NCC and the City of Gatineau would adversely influence a vision that can, and will help all those involved.

 

From information at:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prince_of_Wales_Bridge

http://www.railways.incanada.net

GeoOttawa

 

THE BEACHCOMBER ROOM: Finding Ottawa’s original 1960’s Tiki Bar

photo

A tiki-mug and an original Ottawa Tiki-bar menu.

 

Every city has its favourite night clubs, most of them enjoying the spotlight for a few years before something trendier comes along. Every decade has its hot spots, and in the 1960s, one of the hottest, or should I say coolest night clubs was Ottawa’s “Beachcomber Room”. Located in the Talisman Motor Inn on Carling Avenue, the Beachcomber Room boasted the latest in Tiki culture and entertainment through the vision of  Talisman designer William Teron.

Original 1960s postcard of the Talisman Motor Inn that contained the Beachcomber Room

Original 1960s postcard of the Talisman Motor Inn that contained the Beachcomber Room

Built in 1963 as Ottawa’s premier business convention centre and hotel, Teron designed the Talisman with a South Pacific theme, including a very faithful replica of a tranquil Japanese garden at the center of the motel. The Beachcomber Room was “flamboyantly decorated in a Tahitian motif” and also featured a 90-foot mural painted by Count Alex Van Svodoba, who also completed a mural at Carleton University.

The Talisman Motor Inn as it appeared in 1989. All original signs have since been removed.

The Talisman Motor Inn as it appeared in 1989. All original signs have since been removed.

 

The Polynesian theme of the Beachcomber Room was in tune with the popularity of the Tiki culture during the mid-century era, which was based primarily on “Don the Beachcomber’s” in Hollywood, California. Credited as being the first tiki restaurant that all others copied, its founder, Donn Beach, was the first to mix flavored syrups and fresh fruit juices with rum. The trend became the hot ticket for Hollywood stars and elite, making the Tiki-theme a nationwide phenomenon.  Ottawa was no exception, with The Tabu opening in the old Beacon Arms Hotel (now the Capital Hotel & Suites) in the early sixties and The Beachcomber Room opening soon afterwards in 1963, taking its name directly from the original Hollywood establishment.

A newspaper ad from the Ottawa Citizen describing the Beachcomber Room with its GO-Go Girls and

A newspaper ad from a late 1960s Ottawa Citizen describing the Beachcomber Room with its GO-Go Girls to make “you surge with emotion”

Enjoying almost three decades of popularity as Ottawa’s hottest drinking and entertainment establishment, the Beachcomber Room was THE place to dance, listen to live music and enjoy the quintessential Tiki Mai Tai cocktail. However, as with most bars, its popularity wained and the Talisman name was dropped when it became a Travelodge and it was extensively renovated with a Kids Water Park and its unique Polynesian theme was lost.  Remnants of the Japanese gardens are still visible today, as are some architectural details from its illustrious past. But where was the Beachcomber Room? What is left of it? Lets comb the beach…

Approaching the old Talisman, its unique 1960s architectural style by Bill Teron is still evident.

Approaching the old Talisman, its unique 1960s architectural style by Bill Teron is still evident.

Original postcard of the Talisman central Japanese Garden...

Original postcard of the Talisman central Japanese Garden…

...and that same view as it looks today.

…and that same view as it looks today.

Some left over relics from the old South Pacific themed Talisman can be spotted around the present day hotel, like this Japanese hutch.

Some left over relics from the old South Pacific themed Talisman can be spotted around the present day hotel, like this Japanese hutch.

More relics of the Talisman's glorious Polynesian past...some wall hangings on a wall hidden by an emergency exit.

More relics of the Talisman’s glorious Polynesian past…some Asian style wall hangings on a wall hidden away by an emergency exit.

A 1963 newspaper article describes the Beachcomber Room as being "downstairs"

A 1963 newspaper article describes the Beachcomber Room as being in a “lower lobby” – Ottawa Citizen

A clue...marked on an old sign in the stairway is "BEACHCOMBER ROOM"

A clue…marked on an old sign in the stairway is “BEACHCOMBER ROOM”

Another sign clue is leading us downstairs in the direction of the Beachcomber Room.

Another sign clue is leading us downstairs in the direction of the Beachcomber Room.

...and there it is. I have no idea what lies behind those doors and if the original 1963 Polynesian themed mural by Count Alex Von Svodoba is still in there.

…and there it is. I have no idea what lies behind those doors and if the original 1963 Polynesian themed mural by Count Alex Von Svodoba is still in there.

These abandonedf stairs would have lead you down to Ottawa's hottest nightclub, the long lost original tiki-bar known as...THE BEACHCOMBER ROOM.

These abandoned snow-covered stairs lead down to what was once Ottawa’s hottest nightclub, the long lost original tiki-bar known as…THE BEACHCOMBER ROOM.

The current hotel website says you can rent out the 5600 square foot "Beachcomber Room"....Tiki-party anyone?

The current hotel website says you can rent out the legendary “Beachcomber Room”….Tiki-party anyone?

NO VACANCY: Remains of Mid-Century Motels found in the woods

Titlecard

This past week I had the opportunity to join Glen Gower from Ottawa Start on a search for the remains of two 1950s motels lost in the woods of the NCC Greenbelt. Here is what we found…

INTRODUCTION BY GLEN GOWER, OttawaStart

A long-time Glen Cairn resident told me recently about an old swing set that he once saw in the greenbelt along the Old Quarry Trail on the south side of Robertson Road. He said he thought it was part of one of an old motel that used to be along the road, before the NCC bought the land and designated it as Greenbelt.

It turns out there was not one, but two motels. Charlie’s Motel and the Cedarview Motel are visible on a 1976 aerial map of Ottawa. Charlie’s has a distinctive striped roof. Back then Robertson Road was known as “Highway 7” or “Highway 15”. Long before the Queensway was built, it was the route to get from Ottawa to Perth and beyond. So these would have been a popular stop for travellers going to or from Ottawa.

Starting out from the Old Quarry Trail parking lot on Eagleson Road, we set out to see if anything was left of the motels. Our cameras froze and we had to crawl along in the snow at one point, but we found what we were looking for. Not the swings, but something even more interesting…

NO VACANCY: The Search for the Lost Motels

When Glen told me about a story of a hiker who stumbled across the remains of an old motel playground, I was interested in teaming up on an expedition to find it. Doing some preliminary research on the possibility of a lost motel in the woods of the NCC Greenbelt, I referred to a 1965 aerial image of the area to see what was there. Sure enough, not one, but TWO Motels can clearly be seen in the aerial image.

a 1965 aerial image clearly shows two motels in the area of Robertson Road west of Bells Corners.

A 1965 aerial image clearly shows two motels in the area of Robertson Road west of Bells Corners.

The two motels are still visible in this 1976 aerial image.

The two motels are still visible in this 1976 aerial image.

A current aerial image shows the motels have vanished and are now part of the NCC Greenbelt.

A current aerial image shows the motels have vanished and are now part of the NCC Greenbelt.

Taking those images and overlaying them on a current aerial image provided a bearing on the approximate locations. We then started some historical research…What were these places? What happened to them?

A quick search of what motels could have been in the area showed that the stretch of road they were on was once called the “Whiskey Road” in the mid 1800s. This was due to the fact there were so many taverns in the vicinity, as this was a midway point between Ottawa and Richmond while travelling on Richmond Road between the two places. Now part of what is called Bells Corners and Robertson Road, it was also once known as “Old Highway 15 & 7” during the mid-20th century. It was a stretch of road that was a continuation of both Highway 7 & and Highway 15 and was the only corridor into Ottawa from the West. Being so, a number of motels begand to spring up along this road, most notably during the 1950s when “motoring” was a popular tourist activity, and “Motor Inns” or “Motels” became a popular option for weary drivers and their passengers.

An internet search yielded results for two motels on that stretch of road known as “Old Highway 7 & 15”. It was re-named Robertson Road in 1983 after the owner of a general store and surveyor of roads in Bells Corners. The two motels were called “Charlie’s Motel” to the west and “Cedarview Motel” to the east. Locating vintage 1950s postcards of both motels as they appeared in the 1950s,  the bizarre diagonal roof striping as shown on the 1965 aerial photo of  confirm that the postcard was indeed that of Charlie’s Motel.

A 1950s postcard showing "Charlie's Motel". Note the distinctive striped roof.

A 1950s postcard showing “Charlie’s Motel”. Note the distinctive striped roof.

The same distinctive striped roof as shown on the 1965 aerial image close up. A match.

The Cedarview Motel from a 1950s postcard. (delcampe)

The Cedarview Motel from a 1950s postcard. (delcampe)

A 1965 aerial image close-up showing the Cedarview Motel. Note swimming pool at centre.

A 1965 aerial image close-up showing the Cedarview Motel. Note swimming pool at centre.

The Cedarview Motel gained some notoriety in 1961 when a helicopter pilot en route from Montreal landed his helicopter at the motel for dinner and an overnight stay, which made the news in the Ottawa Citizen.

sdwrfwf

A clipping from the Ottawa Citizen of a guest who landed a helicopter at the Cedarview for dinner and night’s stay.

With both motels now known and identities confirmed, a further search history showed that both motels were later purchased by the National Capital Commision who bought the properties, left them abandoned, which later resulted in the Cedarview burning to the ground, and Charlie’s being demolished. An Ottawa Citizen article from 1965 shows that the NCC had at that time purchased the land and was leasing it to Charlie’s Motel proprietor Howard Soucie for a three year contract.

A 1965 Ottawa Citizen article shows the motel land had already been purchased by the NCC who then leased it back to the motel.

A 1965 Ottawa Citizen article shows the motel land had already been purchased by the NCC who then leased it back to the motel.

The abandoned Cedarview Motel burned down in 1979. (image courtesy Christopher Ryan/Ottawa Journal)

The abandoned Cedarview Motel burned down in 1979. (image courtesy Christopher Ryan/Ottawa Journal)

A 1976 aerial image shows both were still in existence at that time, but a 1979 Ottawa Journal article and photo shows that the Cedarview burned down. It is not known when or how Charlie’s Motel met its fate.

THE SEARCH

Overlaying the known locations over a current map Glen and I were able to locate the vicinity of the motels and where the remains of these mid-century motels may lie. Arranging to meet nearby, we happened to pick one of the coldest days of the winter for our expedition, and needless to say, a half hour into our adventure our cameras and batteries began to freeze up. Keeping them close to our bodies for restorative warmth, we trudged through the -20 temperatures and crunching snow to discover the site of Charlie’s Motel.

The site of Charlie's Motel as it appears today.

The site of Charlie’s Motel as it appears today.

Nothing much is left of Charlie’s, just an empty field with some surrounding trees. Perhaps in the summer, more of the ruins are visible, but on our trek, we decided to keep moving through the NCC Greenbelt woodlands towards whatever remained of the Cedarview Motel.

Making our way through the snow covered trees, we came across the area where the Cedarview should be, crawling underneath some fallen cedar branches to get to the site. The whole area was actually full of cedar trees, so we knew this was most likely the home of the “Cedarview Motel”. Aptly named.

Entering the area of the Cedarview Motel.

Entering the area of the Cedarview Motel.

Nothing was readily apparent until we spotted a cedar branch structure that indicated a man-made influence.

A cedar structure was spotted.

The 1965 aerial image of the Cedarview Motel showed it once had an in-ground swimming pool, a feature filled in as shown on the 1976 image. Stumbling through the deep snow we soon came across a clearing with absolutely no vegetation growing on it. Was this the filled in swimming pool? Overgrowth had consumed the Cedarview Motel area, but for some reason, this area was devoid of any trees, which I think would be because the trees would not be able to take root within an in-ground concrete swimming pool.

An odd clearing...likely the swimming pool of the Cedarview Motel.

An odd clearing…likely the swimming pool of the Cedarview Motel.

An inspection of the clearing then revealed something more concrete…literally concrete…the foundation of the old Cedarview Motel.

DISCOVERY

Discovery of the concrete ruins of the Cedarview  Motel.

Discovery of the concrete ruins of the Cedarview Motel.

The concrete foundation of the Cedarview is clearly lying among the overgrown forest of cedars it was aptly named after more than sixty years ago. The long, straight shape of the motel rooms illustrated on the aerial image and on the postcard were discovered buried under the snow, running through the forest of trees that reclaimed the footprint of the original motel. The outline of the motel structure lay hidden in the forest, slowly being enveloped by the cedar forest from which it was named, the only remnants of its fiery demise.

Concrete ruins of the Cedarview Motel.

Concrete ruins of the Cedarview Motel.

Remains of Cedarview Motel.

Forest remains of the Cedarview Motel.

Stanchions sit in the woods from motel days gone by.

Old motel stanchions sit in the woods from motel days gone by.

Close up of what lies beneath the snow.

Close up of what lies beneath the snow.

Concrete forms from the old motel lie quietly resting in the forest of the NCC Greenbelt.

Concrete forms from the old motel lie quietly resting in the forest of the NCC Greenbelt.

The motel area as it appears today....the clearing in the centre is where the swimming pool once was.

The motel area as it appears today….the clearing in the centre is where the swimming pool once was.

Other motel artifacts were discovered as Glen and I searched the area, including concrete forms, barrier posts, more foundations, wooden fence posts and piles of rubble. the majority of the Cedarview Motel lies hidden beneath the forest canopy of cedar trees for which it was named. A hidden reminder of its past accommodating weary motorists on their way to or from the Nation’s Capital. After photographing the area, Glen and I headed back to warm both our cameras and ourselves.

The ruins of the Cedarview and Charlie’s Motel sit silently in the woods of the Greenbelt, a by-product of the NCC’s vision of a green space for the city and its tourists to enjoy, but evidently with no vacancy on Robertson Road.

 

 

SOURCES

geoOttawa

Delcampe Postcards

The Ottawa Journal, Dec. 15 1979

Google News, The Ottawa Citizen, May 21 1965

 

 

THE LEGEND OF LOST GOLD: Buried treasure on the shores of Lake Ontario

lostgold

As a kid growing up on the shores of Eastern Lake Ontario, I had always heard tales of old ships and gunboat battles that occurred in the waters in front of our house near Millhaven, On. With Kingston being a strategic military location throughout Great Lakes history, I always imagined the vessels that may have plied the waters offshore from my home. Tales of mighty gun battles between opposing sides from the 18th and 19th centuries always filled my imagination with shipwrecks, cannon fire and buried treasure. One such tale, perhaps more of a legend, was that of lost gold from a French gunboat during the Seven Years War that apparently still lies buried in the sands of Prince Edward County, about one hour west of Kingston. The gold was reportedly buried in 1758 and never recovered, fuelling local folklore since then. Now, with time I had over the Christmas holidays, and resources never before available, I finally researched this legend of lost gold and hit the sands on a quest for lost gold…

THE STORY 

The Seven Years War pitted British and French against each other on the Great Lakes in a battle to secure Upper Canada and control the area north of the the United States. Gunships from both sides sailed the waters of Lake Ontario, exchanging cannon fire in an attempt to gain lake superiority.

British gun ship fleet from the Seven Years War on Lake Ontario.

British gun ship fleet from the Seven Years War on Lake Ontario.

French gunship fleet on Lake Ontario during the same period of 1758.

French gunship fleet on Lake Ontario during the same period of 1758.

On such incident had a French gunboat sailing across the southern shores of the Eastern end of the lake near what we call the “Gap”, an open space between two of the larger islands on that end. Laden with military documents and a barrel of gold headed to Fort Frontenac (presently Kingston) the French ship was nearing the gap when a Bristish ship under the command of Captain Bradstreet spotted the French vessel on his way across the lake from Oswego, NY.

Captain Bradstreet. British commander of the ship who spotted the French gunboat near Kingston, On.

Captain Bradstreet. British commander of the ship who spotted the French gunboat near Kingston, On.

Bradstreet gave chase to the French ship, cutting it off before it could reach its destination of Fort Frontenac. Evading a most certain engagement and possible capture, the French ship reversed direction and sailed back west trying to escape Bradstreet’s ship. The French ship headed west along the southern edge of what is now Prince Edward County trying to outrun Bradstreet. Realizing evading the British was impossible, the French ship headed for a bay called ‘Little Sandy Bay”.

The Lake Chase Incident of 1758

The Lake Chase Incident of 1758

maplakeontchase2

 

Not giving up, Bradstreet chased the French ship into the bay, and with their fate almost certainly sealed, the French captain beached his ship, ordered the crew to evacuate with the documents and gold, then torched his ship to the ground to avoid it being captured by the British. The captain and crew then headed inland towards their destination of Fort Frontenac on foot, and as the story goes, buried the heavy barrel of gold to return with reinforcements from the fort to retrieve it later. They arrived at Fort Frontenac only to find it had been attacked and destroyed by the British. The gold, now on British controlled land, was never recovered and apparently still lies buried where it was placed over 250 years ago.

A British map of the same area soon after they captured Fort Frontenac.

A British map from 1759 of the same area soon after they captured Fort Frontenac.

 

LEGEND OR TRUTH?

Over the years, the story of the lost gold has evolved through many incarnations, some more fanciful than others, but they all tell of how the gold remains buried and is waiting to be discovered. Always ready to solve a “history mystery”, I thought it would be fun to re-visit the story in more detail and use some new resources that we may not have previously been able to use. One such resource was a book I came across from 1892 that outlines the story in exacting detail…a story I have never seen written down before, which adds some credibility to the story. Next, we can use old maps and overlay them with current satellite imagery to pinpoint exact areas that are mentioned in the 1892 story. Regardless of what we find, it is a fun and interesting exercise with some fascinating results that I will share with you below…

French gold coins from 1758 that may be the ones still buried in the sands of Prince Edward County.

French gold coins from 1758 that may be the ones still buried in the sands of Prince Edward County.

 

THE QUEST

Using the text from the book “Picturesque Prince Edward County” from 1892 that outlines the story, I studies the details mentioned in the account.

The story as re-collected in 1892, 134 years after the incident occurred.

The story as told in 1892, 134 years after the incident occurred.

Carefully noting details in the story, I was able to create a list of landmarks mentioned, and using a map of the same time period in the 1870s, mark them on the map.

A map of the area the French ship apparently entered with the gold. Circa 1878.

A map of the area the French ship apparently entered with the gold. Circa 1878.

“Little Sandy Bay” is shown on the map as well as a bridge and cabin, mentioned in the story where the tale tells us the gold was buried “half-way between the bridge and the bay”…

IMG_3641IMG_3643

 

Now using a current Google satellite map we can overlay it on the old map:

IMG_3645

 

This gives us an approximate location which we can zero in on to explore for more clues…mostly being the location of the “Old Bridge” which no longer exists since new roads have been built since 1878.

Traget area that's the "halfway" point as mentioned.

Traget area that’s the “halfway” point as mentioned.

So with some rough ideas of where the bridge and the half-way point could be, I went off with a neighbour in search of some real evidence to help confirm their existence.

Where the "old bridge" is supposed to be located...sure enough, the foundations remain of this old bridge.

Where the “old bridge” is supposed to be located…sure enough, the foundations remain of this old bridge.

Remnants of the old bridge can be seen where it was indicated on the map.

Remnants of the old bridge can be seen where it was indicated on the map.

Exactly where it is supposed to be is the cabin that is also shown on the old map as a black dot...

Exactly where it is supposed to be is the cabin (dated 1830) that is also shown on the old map as a black dot…

close-up detail of the old map that shows both the old bridge and the log cabin location.

close-up detail of the old map that shows both the old bridge and the log cabin location.

So now that we have confirmed the location of the old bridge, we can now mark the “halfway” point where the gold was buried near a “cofferdam”, which is a small dam that would have built from stones.

16-Section-of-rockfill-cofferdam

Heading to the halfway point and where the cofferdam should be, there are some collapsed stones….

IMG_3660

…but they are now replaced with a modern bridge.

IMG_3651

Could this new bridge have been built upon the old cofferdam location which was the half-way point where the gold is supposedly buried? I decided to explore the rest of the area and see if anything else unusal could be found that may give us some further clues. If not, then at least it would be fun to re-trace the supposed steps of the French captain back to the bay where he burned his ship in 1758.

I explored the riverbanks and re-traced the path of the French captain back to the bay where he burned his ship in 1758.

I explored the riverbanks and re-traced the path of the French captain back to the bay where he burned his ship in 1758.

 

The area is very sandy, and is now part of Sandbanks Provincial Park.

The area is very sandy, and is now part of Sandbanks Provincial Park.

A large man-made mound was discovered on the shoreline walking towards the bay.

A large man-made mound was discovered on the shoreline walking towards the bay.

Further along the river, I came across what looked to be a man-made mound in the forest on the banks of the river. Some cut logs were supporting it, but the date of this structure is unknown.

Some cut logs were supporting the mound structure. Date unknown.

Some cut logs were supporting the mound structure. Date unknown.

Following the river to where it empties into the bay, this is where the gold-laden French ship apparently was beached and burned.

Following the river to where it empties into the bay, this is where the gold-laden French ship apparently was beached and burned.

This is the beach where the ship apparently was burned to avoid being captured.

This is the beach where the ship apparently was burned to avoid being captured.

Looking out towards Lake Ontario and Sandy Bay.

Looking out towards Lake Ontario and Sandy Bay.

Reaching the end point of the quest, which was actually the start point for the French captain in 1758, no gold was recovered nor were there any further clues to investigate. The empty land is part of Sandbanks Provincial Park, and remains as a beautiful place to walk and fuels the imagination as to what may have happened all those years ago according to the recorded tale below from 1892:

image-1

Having successfully re-traced the reported path of the French captain from 1758, the gold could very well still be buried under the shifting sands of the area, and perhaps it will remain as it has for the past 250 years….a LEGEND OF LOST GOLD.

SOURCES

“Picturesque Prince Edward County”, 1892, by Helen Merrill

Google Maps

Hastings and Prince Edward County Historical Atlas, 1878

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Bradstreet

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seven_Years’_War

 

 

IT’S A WONDERFUL TOWN: Exploring what may be the real Bedford Falls from “It’s A Wonderful Life”

IT’S A WONDERFUL TOWN

George Bailey, played by actor Jimmy Stewart in the fictional town of Bedford Falls from "It's A Wonderful Life"

George Bailey, played by actor Jimmy Stewart in the fictional town of Bedford Falls from “It’s A Wonderful Life”

No matter how many times I watch it, I never tire of the holiday classic “It’s A Wonderful Life”. Year after year, Frank Capra’s 1946 film stirs up the Christmas spirit in me more than any other holiday film. Its timeless message of the how the good of mankind ultimately prevails through the hardships of life brings an annual tear to my eye, and for me, captures the true essence of the holiday season.

The film was released in 1946 produced/directed by Frank Capra based on the short story “The Greatest Gift” and features the fictional town of “Bedford Falls” where the life of George Bailey played by actor Jimmy Stewart takes place. Bedford Falls does not really exist, but it bears a remarkable resemblance to a real-life town called “Seneca Falls” in upper New York state. Capra apparently visited Seneca Falls in the 1940’s so perhaps this influenced his screenplay for the film and provided the backdrop for this classic film.

There are numerous references in the film to various places in New York state, including Rochester, Albany and Syracuse, all towns that are in close proximity to the real life Seneca Falls. So let’s visit Seneca Falls through the use of technology and Google Streetview maps to see what other similarities may exist in this wonderful town….

Map showing the location of Seneca Falls, the town that may have inspired the film location for "It's A Wonderful Life"

Map showing the location of Seneca Falls, the town that may have inspired the film location for “It’s A Wonderful Life”

 

The town of Seneca Falls that shows the main street, bridge and other elements that are similar to those in the film.

The town of Seneca Falls that shows the main street, bridge and other elements that are similar to those in the film.

 

A key element in the film is the bridge from where George Bailey jumps into the icy waters below...this bridge bears a close resemblence to the bridge in the film.

A key element in the film is the bridge from where George Bailey jumps into the icy waters below…this bridge bears a close resemblence to the bridge in the film.

 

Here we see George on the bridge in the film, and on the right, the bridge in Seneca Falls.

Here we see George on the bridge in the film, and on the right, the bridge in Seneca Falls.

 

A Google streetview allows us to cross the bridge.

A Google streetview allows us to cross the bridge.

 

Zooming in on a streetview of the bridge there is a plaque notcieable....

Zooming in on a streetview of the bridge there is a plaque noticeable….


A closer photo of the plaque on the bridge indicates an incident where a man jumped into the river to save someone's life, remarkably similar to the plot point in the film where George jumps off the bridge to save the life of a drowning man. Was this incident the inspiration for Capra's film?

A closer photo of the plaque on the bridge indicates an incident where a man jumped into the river to save someone’s life, remarkably similar to the plot point in the film where George jumps off the bridge to save the life of a drowning man. Was this incident the inspiration for Capra’s film?

Google streetview reveals the name of the street the bridge is on. Clarence was the angel in the film that George rescues from the river.

Google streetview reveals the name of the street the bridge is on. Clarence was the angel in the film that George rescues from the river.

 

 

An old hotel on the other side of the bridge is also named the "Hotel Clarence"

An old hotel on the other side of the bridge is also named the “Hotel Clarence”

 

The main street of Seneca Falls looks a lot like the film version of the town that's called Bedford Falls.

The main street of Seneca Falls looks a lot like the film version of the town that’s called Bedford Falls.

 

Is this building on the main street the inspiration for the Bailey Building and Loan business featured in the film?

Is this building on the main street the inspiration for the Bailey Building and Loan business featured in the film?

 

Mr. Potter, the greedy villain in the film shares some interesting similarities to Seneca Falls resident, Mr. Gould, a businessman that owned a lot of the town and properties and was involved with politics. Gould also owned the hotel and was known to drive around town in a large expensive automobile.

Mr. Potter, the greedy villain in the film shares some interesting similarities to Seneca Falls resident, Mr. Gould, a businessman that owned a lot of the town and properties and was involved with politics. Gould also owned the hotel and was known to drive around town in a large expensive automobile.

 

Perhaps these similarities are pure coincidence, but it does make one wonder if the real life town of  Seneca Falls was the basis for "It's A Wonderful Life" Merry Christmas!

Perhaps these similarities are pure coincidence, but it does make one wonder if the real life town of Seneca Falls was the basis for “It’s A Wonderful Life”
Merry Christmas!

Remains Of 140 year old Canadian Pacific Railway Still On NCC Parkway

LRT2014

Recently the NCC announced their plans to re-route the LRT line away from the original Sir John A MacDonald Parkway (SJAM). The City Of Ottawa favoured this plan, but the NCC wants to have the rail line cross the NCC owned Rochester Field, beside Keg Manor on Richmond Rd. This route option would mean the rail line would have to come along either the Byron Linear path or Richmond Road, crossing over into Rochester Field and connect to the already existing OC transitway trench.

The City Of Ottawa plans used a 1.2km connection stretch from Lincoln Fields to the Transitway trench using a path along the SJAM. The NCC says that area is off-limits unless it is buried underground and does not impede access to the river. The NCC favoured route has the rail line using Rochester Field saying “It would be up to the city to determine if a transit line that extends up from Rochester Field would be a tunnel, buried below grade, or run on grade.”

This means the connection this cross-over would have to use either the Byron Linear Path from Lincoln Fields or Richmond Rd for the rail line.

The City’s approach, and the one favoured for the final plan of the western LRT route uses a 1.2km strip of the SJAM. This strip would be located on the southern edge of the SJAM. After doing some research, it seems this strip was actually already a rail line used by the Canadian Pacific Railway for almost 100 years from 1870 1967.


LRTwide1965LRTwide2011

Remains of this CP rail route, the line the LRT would run along, are still there if we go and take a closer look.

A Canadian Pacific train like this one would have travelled along the SJAM in 1958. (City Of Ottawa archives photo)

A Canadian Pacific train like this one would have travelled along the SJAM in 1958. (City Of Ottawa archives photo)

CPlinebridge1958markedCpbridge1965CPlinebridgenowmarked

 

The CP line runs exactly along the same path as the planned LRT line, although now overgrown, the path follows the same route as trains once did 50 years ago. Looking at aerial photos of the area with the old CP line in place and overlaying a current aerial image, we can see where the rail line was. A closer look at old aerial photos reveals a train bridge that CP built at some point. Overlaying that photo over a current aerial image showed the location and so I went there to check it out. Although crumbling and graffiti covered, the leaves have fallen away to reveal this relic of our railway past that still lies on the NCC property exactly the same way it has since 1870.

The CP Rail bridge as it looks today on NCC SJAM Parkway

The CP Rail bridge as it looks today on NCC SJAM Parkway

Crumbling remains of 140 year old CP Rail Line.

Crumbling remains of 140 year old CP Rail Line.

Hidden by trees and bushes in the summer, the old CP line bridge on NCC property where the proposed LRT route is to go on the SJAM parkway would use this exact same old rail line route.

Hidden by trees and bushes in the summer, the old CP line bridge on NCC property where the proposed LRT route is to go on the SJAM parkway would use this exact same old rail line route.

I walked the entire route of the old CP rail line, the route of the old track is still there on the SJAM, unimpeded by trees and a clear stretch right up to where the location of the old Westboro Canadian Pacific train station used to be at the end of Roosevelt St. Built in 1919 and demolished in 1960, the train station is now where the OC Transitway trench is.

westendstationmarkedwestendstationnowmarked

The Canadian Pacific Railway Station in Westboro at the end of Roosevelt St.

The Canadian Pacific Railway Station in Westboro in 1952 at the end of Roosevelt St.

westborotrain stationghost

samehousetrainstation

Where the CP Westboro train station was…as it looks today.

 

This sidewalk follows the exact same railway route of the Canadian Pacific line 1870-1967.

This sidewalk follows the exact same railway route of the Canadian Pacific line 1870-1967.

Both the NCC and the City options have their individual pros and cons, and it seems no one will be happy no matter what route is chosen, but perhaps by looking at our past it can lead us to a solution for the future.

 

SOURCES

http://www.railways.incanada.net

Google Maps

GEO-Ottawa